Magellan (2017)

Good movie but grossly overrated

Good films always raise compelling questions, whether the format is fiction or documentary fact.

The story, direction, characters, and writing/dialogue is akin to taking a tranquilizer shot to the neck, but everything else was so well done.

The film's masterful storytelling did its job. The message was clear. No need to overdo.

I realize that different people have different reasons for watching science fiction films. What matters to me is the plot, not the budget for special effects, sets, and costumes. The plot of this movie is suspenseful, well-paced, and thought-provoking. A refreshing change from the proliferation of movies that consist of nonstop, mind-numbing battle scenes and explosions.

Overall, I thought the acting and plot were good although it was truly unbelievable to have NASA send only 1 astronaut on this type of mission. It wouldn't happen, IMO. Due to the low budget I cannot complain about the special effects, scenery etc. I actually thought the exterior space scenes with the space craft, planets, moons etc. were very well done given the low budget. I also felt the scriptwriter was sloppy in creating tension with regards to the time Roger was given to retrieve the 2nd sphere. Given his location when told he had 15 mins to retrieve the object, return to his ship and launch in order to not miss the launch window for the 3rd destination was very unrealistic. And given his actions, the accidents that occurred and the fact that the writer did not allow for him to secure the box to his suit with a lanyard freeing up his hands was really sloppy. I wasn't afraid for him at all, just bored and angry at the writer at the same time. All that being said, I was really interested in the story and wanted know what was going to happen next. As for the ending, I really wanted them get Roger to the 4th destination instead of ending at the start of that mission. Maybe end it when he got to the 4th destination. Except for the issues discussed previously, I enjoyed the movie and if a sequel is made, I will watch it.

Laughable from start to finish. This movies sparse set, boring and uninspired script, and horrendous special effects result in a poor man's version of 2001: A Space Odyssey. A very poor man's version.

Another thoughtful plot ruined by an inexperienced cast of writers/producers/director/actors. If you want your movie to be taken seriously by the audience, then YOU take it seriously in preparation and execution - newsflash(!) it doesn't require a big budget. This was yet another lazy attempt to explore an endlessly fascinating situation.