A Free Soul (1931)

Don't listen to the negative reviews

While it doesn't offer any answers, it both thrills and makes you think.

This movie tries so hard to be funny, yet it falls flat every time. Just another example of recycled ideas repackaged with women in an attempt to appeal to a certain audience.

All of these films share one commonality, that being a kind of emotional center that humanizes a cast of monsters.

Excellent film where alcoholic attorney and widower,played by Lionel Barrymore in a truly Oscar-winning performance, sets out defending and getting off gangster-gambler Clark Gable, (Ace Wilpon) only to have the latter fall for his daughter, Norma Shearer. While Barrymore was fabulous here, Shearer gave another of her gut-wrenching performances, starting off as a free soul, not wanting to marry the erudite suitor Leslie Howard. View how she changes as she falls for the Gable character. Seeing what Gable really is, Shearer wants no part of him and is threatened along with Howard.Barrymore is forced to defend the Howard character when he kills Gable. That court room scene is absolutely memorable where Barrymore admits to court that he failed his daughter for not being there.Frustrated, and a confirmed drinker, Barrymore came from a strong upper class family. Family values are well depicted here as well.

At some point in a courtroom scene, someone says, "This is too theatrical." His comment fits a description of this Clarence Brown movie that features NORMA SHEARER, LESLIE HOWARD and LIONEL BARRYMORE in leading roles.But the actor who commands the most attention whenever he appears is CLARK GABLE, then being groomed for stardom by MGM. He was given another "dangerous guy" role as a gangster who had once been a client of Shearer's father (Barrymore) and set free. Complications ensue when Shearer falls in love with the man she treats as a "boy toy" and the melodrama gets steamier when Leslie Howard has to protect her by shooting Gable.Remade in the '50s for an Elizabeth Taylor film called "The Girl Who Had Everything," it's hampered by the '31 conventions of early talkies, all of them featuring performers who were still using silent film technique for their acting styles. Thus, you can expect a lot of overacting, especially from Lionel Barrymore who uses all of his mannerisms to the nth degree in the final courtroom confrontation. Yet, he won a Best Actor Oscar for his very theatrical performance.Summing up: It's a matter of taste--and whether or not you can tolerate all the talky dialogue played out in stage-like fashion by a cast of talented players trying to make the transition to sound films. Of the cast members, it's Clark Gable who actually gives the most natural performance in the film--and whom one can easily spot as a candidate for stardom.

Norma Shearer slinks and giggles her way through another melodrama, this one noted for not only her but the presence of Lionel Barrymore, Clark Gable and Leslie Howard. Not a bad cast, eh?The story has a lot to it, too - too much to go into here. It's basically a father-daughter story with the daughter having a good guy and a bad guy both after her, and her taking in all the attention she can get. I've only seen two Norma Shearer films but she played a similar character in both. She's likes to giggle, show off her body and flirt but doesn't want commitments. (The Divorcée was the other film in which I saw her.) For much of this film, this is a gender-reversal with the woman being the "heel."Barrymore plays her dad, an alcoholic defense attorney. If, for nothing else in this movie, he's remembered for his impassioned speech at the end of the trial. It WILL get your attention! Clark Gable plays the toughie and Howard plays the suave nice-guy both vying for Shearer's love.There is truth to a number of things in this film such as "Jan Ashe" (Shearer) finding the not-so-nice guy more "exciting" over a genuine gentleman. Why many women are like that - preferring the grubby-looking thug - who knows, but Shearer is good at playing that role. Shearer's Harlow-like attire and no-bra look got my (and Gable's) attention, too.The movie should be enjoyed by most who like this kind of a melodrama and/or appreciate good acting and a bit of star-gazing.

One of the interesting things for me was seeing Clark Gable and Lesley Howard act together 8 yrs prior to Gone with the Wind. Kind of the same casting type-Lesley Howard the smart,cool headed guy and Clark Gable hotheaded, physical type.Maybe that was why I was shocked at how the LH character handled the situation with CG. This is the first time I've seen Lionel Barrymore in a lead role and was thinking he should have at least been nominated for an Oscar,so looked it up,and was pleased to see he won! Very deserved.I have an etching done by Lionel that my Mom had that shows his great talent in that area also. I saw this on Turner Classic Movies, after seeing the documentary about why the codes started. For it's time this is a very in your face movie. Alcohol abuse,co-habitating with no marriage. The obvious threat of an abusive marriage,or worse if she refuses the marriage. Also loved the scenes of 1931 San Francisco thru the window at the beginning, Yosemite and other areas.