Eric & Ernie (2011)

Great Film overall

Boring

Beautiful, moving film.

This film is so real. It treats its characters with so much care and sensitivity.

Morecambe and Wise aren't part of my cultural heritage (I guess the equivalent comedy team in my childhood would be Wayne and Shuster) but I had no trouble enjoying this without reference to the originals. Of course comedy is very time and place specific so it's virtually impossible to actually BE funny while playing funny people from another place and time. But Daniel Rigby and Bryan Dick radiate so much charm and energy as Eric and Ernie that I can easily imagine them becoming big stars.It must have been the sequence in the burlesque theater that made me think of "Gypsy." There are certainly parallels between these two dramatizations of the early lives of stars and their stage mothers. Victoria Wood was casting herself very much against type as Mama Sadie, bullying and manipulating her son Eric into a stage career he never wanted. Now I'm thinking of Imelda Staunton's Mama Rose, which captured the monstrous ambition of the character without her seductive charm (I'm sorry but there is no way in hell that Staunton could ever been seen to have made a damn good stripper.) Wood herself would have been terribly cast as Rose--she was a crooner, not a belter. But her own warm, vulnerable persona radiates through Sadie's ruthlessness, and her version of "Rose's Turn"--weeping quietly after Eric and Ernie have informed her they've hired a proper manager and packed her off into a first-class train carriage home--is just as touching as Wood meant it to be.

Morecambe and Wise remain to this day one of the best double acts of all time and this great drama from the BBC shows us their early years. We all know what happened when they achieved fame so it is nice that this drama focuses on the other side of the coin.The casting in this is great. All the actors playing Morecambe and Wise not only look the part but capture the voice and characteristics of the two men and in some places you start to think you're watching the real men.Victoria Wood is also great as Sadie, Eric's mother and her story arc is at the centre of this piece that is beautifully captured by director Johnny Campbell.My only grumble is that much like every other media piece surrounding the comedians this drama is centred more on Eric than Ernie but otherwise this is a great drama.

Like nearly everyone in the UK I am a huge fan of Morecambe and Wise. I truly believe that they were probably the greatest comedy double act ever. So I watched Victoria Woods biography of Eric and Ernie s early years with a little trepidation. I really shouldn't have worried. The BBC have obviously pulled out all the stops. Eric and Ernie is a master class in how to honour two show biz legends. The writing, direction and especially the performances were simply perfection. Daniel Rigby and Bryan Dick were spot on. They managed to show the friendship between Eric and Ernie without lapsing into parody. Special mention should be made of Vic Reeves who played Eric's dad, George. The part was played with quiet humour and dignity and Victoria wood was especially good as Eric's pushy mother. The only reason that I have given Eric and Ernie 9 out of 10 is that I had a small pang of regret when the credits rolled. I really wished that I could had maybe half an hour more. maybe showing more of the great years of Morecambe and Wise. Maybe one day they could make a sequel, but only if its up to this standard.

Eric and Ernie is an accurate portrayal of the early lives of John Eric Bartholomew and Ernest Wiseman, who became household names as the popular double act Morecambe and Wise in the '60s. The story starts just before the duo met and traces their relationship through until the beginning of their successful television careers. It is told with great love and reverence though does not leave out the initial animosity felt by Eric towards the slightly older and somewhat arrogant Ernie who was already a successful child performer, nor his dislike of dancing lessons. The only significant omission, in my view, was their separation during the war when the friends were conscripted and Ernie joined the Merchant Navy while Eric was sent down the mines as a Bevin Boy to help the war effort. Eric's parents are portrayed with great tenderness by Viv Reeve and Victoria Wood. Casting two northern comics for these roles was genius as they are brought to life as natural humorists without falling into the trap of casting Eric's mother, Sadie, as simply a domineering stage mum. Ernie's own family come to life by the fact of being completely absent from the tale. There are no great surprises for anyone who knows of their early lives and careers nor any revelations or secrets revealed but it tells a fascinating tale of how two men who became comedic partners as child performers could have kept their act and their friendship fresh and vibrant throughout their acquaintance and comic careers. It is not over sentimental and is unlikely to make you cry, unless it is as a result of the laugh out loud moments with Eric's off the cuff wit and banter with his friend. I can recommend this portrayal to any fan of Morecambe and Wise - no childhood illusions will be shattered here. This is also a good introduction to anyone who does not know their work. I hope it will inspire people to find their old recordings of their various shows though you might want to miss out their early TV experience in Running Wild.