Oh, Susanna (1936)

Highly Overrated But Still Good

A Disappointing Continuation

This movie tries so hard to be funny, yet it falls flat every time. Just another example of recycled ideas repackaged with women in an attempt to appeal to a certain audience.

what a terribly boring film. I'm sorry but this is absolutely not deserving of best picture and will be forgotten quickly. Entertaining and engaging cinema? No. Nothing performances with flat faces and mistaking silence for subtlety.

Oh, Susanna! (1936). In this unusual but even more ridiculously far-fetched plot, Gene Autry, would you believe, is wanted for murder? Perhaps Republic boss, Herb Yates, firmly believed that Texas lawmen were not only corrupt but incredibly stupid? Never mind, just sit back and enjoy the fast action. Director Joe Kane even has a couple of speeding cars run over the camera! This time, Smiley Burnette teams up with Earle Hodgins to provide not only comedy relief but acting support for Autry's rather stoic hunted man. And railroad buffs will have a ball at the beginning of the movie when the villain's very obvious double boards a moving train from horseback!

In his first full year of turning out B-Westerns, Gene stars in this one that has a different slant than many of his films. He is knocked out early by a prison escapee and thrown off a train; the escapee, Wolf Benson, then heads for a ranch operated by a friend of Autry's from many years before, to masquerade as Gene Autry and try to wheedle a big "loan" from the man.Meanwhile, Gene is found, just coming back to consciousness, by Smiley Burnette and Earle Hodgins, a two-man traveling medicine show. They take Autry to the nearest town, where he was heading anyway, with them being unaware (and evidently Gene is, too) that Benson changed clothes with Autry while he was unconscious, and that the clothing he is now wearing is depicted on a "wanted" poster of Benson. Autry winds up being arrested and thrown in jail as "Wolf Benson".The story goes on from there, with Gene and the "good folks" from his friend's ranch coming out on top at the end -- naturally.This movie has some fine music of the early Western Swing variety, including two songs by the famous band the Light Crust Doughboys. In addition, Gene does a brief riding stunt about halfway through, standing up in his saddle as Champion gallops alone. Did he do it himself? Or was it "obviously a stunt man," as the Autry haters who post most of the reviews of his movies would insist? I don't know; could have been either way.And for the first, but not the last, time in his movies, Gene displays his ability to spin a lariat, a la Will Rogers. Not as well as Rogers could, but he does it. Autry often used his lariat in movies, usually to lasso an escaping bad guy.As I said above, this is a "different" B-Western. But then, most of Gene's were, with a mix between the "Old" and the "New" Wests. Of course, the Autry haters voice frequent dislike of this. But it's just what makes Autry's movies unique -- an element of fantasy. And the American people loved it, with Gene being the leading movie cowboy for six straight years, from 1937 to 1942. They loved the Singing Cowboy. Some of the people who post on here, obviously don't. Well, that's their problem. Gene cried all the way to the bank.

According to the records this was Gene's 12th film - with June Storey nowhere in sight yet but with the formula of chasing baddies with a few songs and a tiny romance that wouldn't bother the kids well in place.It starts with a baddie being chased by the law, jumping onto a moving train, immediately coshing the unsuspecting Autry, thieving his identity and dumping him overboard to his supposed death. All in a minute's work! However, the dazed Gene gets picked up by two travelling entertainers, one of them Frog, and the hunt is on to track the baddie and his gang down who are using his name and not in vain. Favorite songs: Dear Old Western Skies and Water Wheel, while the Light Crust Doughboys got to do a breakneck Tiger Rag and As Our Pals Ride By that put me in mind of La Golondrina from The Wild Bunch. Gene has his usual whirlwind romance, this time with Frances Grant for their 2nd time.At only 53 minutes long a lot gets packed in here, whether you think it was worth it is up to you, but personally I've always enjoyed Autry's films - nothing heavy to ponder about during or afterwards. I have no problem enjoying things meant to be pleasant. It's freely available as public domain on the internet too, the only cost to really consider being your time.

This is a fairly early film from Gene Autrys career.I bought the VHS by air mail.I have to say that the manufacturers have copied from a very battered print.So much so that the film is stated to be 59 minutes in length but in fact is only 53 minutes.I have to say that the fact that it is entertaining is despite not because of the screenplay.The plot hinges on the fact that nobody can recognized Autry and therefore accept that because an escaped murderer has changed clothes with him he is the murderer and vice versa.At the end there is a fight on a moving car which defies logic.However there are the usual quota of songs,although i believe that one or two may be missing.To conclude it will entertain you if you are an enthusiast of Western films.Otherwise you would be better off spending 53minutes digging in the garden.