Natalee Holloway (2009)

Wow! Such a good movie.

Absolutely Fantastic

A Masterpiece!

Good films always raise compelling questions, whether the format is fiction or documentary fact.

The true story of Alabama teenager Natalie Halloway, who went missing while on a class trip in Aruba in 2005 and the subsequent desperate search by her mother (Tracy Pollen) for the truth behind her disappearance.This is another one of those ripped from the headlines, made for TV dramatizations, that I tend to watch when I don't feel like thinking too hard. This one was just okay. I found Tracy Pollen's character to be very annoying and then I realized that was how she was supposed to be as the mother.An interesting story that is made even more so because at the end you are left with more questions than answers. The mystery remains unsolved even with a video confession. I did find myself annoyed by the constant "if this was America" preaching. You're not in America and things are done differently in other countries. 08.13

I caught this LMN movie after seeing its sequel, released earlier this year. This one holds up just as well.Again, Tracy Pollan is a surprise as the mother whom Joran van der Sloot never dreamed would haunt his every move. She is superb as a woman so focused on finding justice for her daughter that she alienates most of the people who support her, including her second husband.The "prequel" to this notorious case is presented intriguingly. Natalee comes across as a young woman in a bubble -- pretty and talented and somewhat indulged by her proud mother. Having seemingly been sheltered all her life, she was even less prepared for a long weekend in a foreign country than her similarly blonde girlfriends. Her fatal naiveté is depicted heartbreakingly here.I found it interesting that the Pollan character, Beth Twitty, seemed to find some peace in an explanation of the crime that an ambushed Joran gave to a person whom he thought was a drug dealer offering him work. (She seemed far less sure of this story in the sequel to this film, which mainly depicts Beth pursuing Joran to get an explanation straight from him.) Another intriguing angle was this movie's effort to show the corruption of law enforcement in Aruba, a little island whose reputation will forever be tainted by the lax and unhelpful attitude Twitty encountered.In all, a compelling depiction of what can be the extreme unfairness of life. My only quibble is that the movie probably should have been titled "Beth Twitty."

What an ironic movie. This Natalee Holloway story is just another girl disappearing on a holiday. I never got why everybody was making such a big deal out of it. Why is this case so special? Because really girls disappear everyday and i'm also horrified by it but making a movie about this case is just fishing for money over the heads of unfortunate people.The thing i'm most discussed about is that this movie gives a wrong image about Aruba. Stereotyping the Aruban people in this movie is just unfair. They are portrayed as wrong and bad people and that no one should ever go to the island. The police is being called corrupt and imaged as bandits. Its often said in the movie that ''they'' just don't care and are not trying there best to find Natalee. Quite ironic though, i wonder how many little girls get abused and murdered in the states everyday. Not to talk about teenagers from the states going to Mexico. I'd like to see some movies of those cases.Really this movie doesn't even deserve one star, because the acting and writing are also horrible. Its just a cheap flick made by gold-diggers that try to get more money over the death of an innocent girl, well personally i think it's sick. There's not a lesson to be learned from this movie so i suggest not to even bother.1/10

While the performances are predictable and the story, well, we can see the same theme on "Nancy Grace"/HLN News every evening, it is important for teens and people traveling to small countries to be aware of the facts presented in this film.Tracy Pollan is believable as Natalee Holloway's mother, a woman who is enraged and galvanized into action when she realizes the death of her daughter was covered up, the perpetrators protected. While certainly this is an upsetting situation, the victim herself was caught in a situation, not realizing the possible outcome.I would suggest that schools promoting such trips be required to provide more guidelines, partying and having fun is all well and good, but when you are in a foreign country, especially if a female,and alone, you need to know how to protect yourself. Teens who have never traveled can scarcely be expected to safeguard against things they have never been made aware of.The reality is that there is no such thing as international law. I was told this in Acapulco, after being injured in a hotel, the hotel paid the medical expenses, but the fact is that, if you are traveling to other countries you need to be aware of their laws. You must be aware of how to protect yourself, and please don't expect the American Embassy to help (See the films "Red Corner" with Richard Gere, and "Midnight Express" with Brad Davis).Worth seeing for the message. Recommended. 7/10.