Donald's Better Self (1938)

Please don't spend money on this.

Beautiful, moving film.

Although it has its amusing moments, in eneral the plot does not convince.

It's the kind of movie you'll want to see a second time with someone who hasn't seen it yet, to remember what it was like to watch it for the first time.

This is a fun little cartoon short from Disney, featuring Donald Duck as a schoolboy. Here, Donald meets his conscience, who resembles him and wears a white robe and a golden halo. She attempts to get Donald to get out of bed and go to school, but gets a run-in from Donald's anti-conscience, dunning a red cape and red horns, who tries to have Donald stay in bed. What results is a back and forth battle for Donald between the good and bad consciences. It's OK for a few laughs and it's somewhat entertaining to see some good vs. evil action going on. The good conscience wants Donald to go to school while the bad conscience wants him to go fishing instead, among of things.Despite Donald being in this cartoon, there isn't a whole lot of laughable moments or comedy you'd come to expect from Donald, but it's still not a bad cartoon short - a good lesson about right and wrong.Grade B-

I have always loved Donald Duck, he is my personal favourite of him, Mickey and Goofy and I love all three in their own way. Donald's Better Self is not one of my favourites from Donald, but I still liked it a lot. I do remember seeing it with a friend a couple of years back and she commented that while she appreciated some aspects she felt that it took much time getting the morals about but it forgot to entertain. I disagree somewhat. Maybe it is a little preachy somewhat with the go to school and never smoke messaging(and I am still not entirely sure about what anti-smoking message was trying to be conveyed), but I don't think it forgets to entertain. Yes, there are definitely funnier Donald cartoons elsewhere, but there are still some good gags like the at the start with Donald being told get out of bed/stay in bed and the devil telling Donald to go to the fishing hole and smoke a pipe. The story is very interesting too, the concept is not necessarily a fresh one but I did love how much of a psychological approach there was here, both in what both the angel and devil tell Donald to do and how Donald reacts to them. The animation is simpler in style, but still colourful and smooth, and the music has a lot of vigorous energy. Donald is like a child here and is fun to watch, but the angel and devil I found to be even more interesting to watch, I love their contrasting personalities and also their well-spoken voices. Clarence Nash is very good as ever as Donald. Overall, a good story and characters lifts an interesting cartoon, even if the morals may come across as preachy to some and you may question the significance of the anti-smoking message. 8/10 Bethany Cox

One bright sunny morning, young Donald Duck was still fast asleep. The alarm clock went off, Donald's good-self angel woke up, and tried to get Donald up too, but his bad-self devil convinced him to stay in bed. The angel tried getting Donald up so he wouldn't be late for school. Donald finally got up, put on his hat, grabbed his books and he and the angel trotted off to school. On the way, Donald met up with the devil again, who coaxed Donald to play hooky and go fishing instead. Down at the river, the devil tried getting Donald to smoke a pipe, saying it would put hair on his chest, which is the last thing a duck would need. So, Donald succumbed to temptation and tried the pipe. He started to feel very sick afterwords, with the devil laughing. By now, the angel realized Donald was no longer following him, so he went looking for him. The angel found Donald and the devil by the lake. Donald was still weary after his very first smoke. Angel tried to get the devil to stop what he was doing, but didn't want to fight. Needless to say the devil had the advantage. He knocked the angel right into the water. Fortunately, after wringing out his halo, the angel got even with the devil and sent him back far down below where he came from. As for Donald, he had learned his lesson and would go to school. So he proudly marched back to the schoolhouse, marching so proudly he marched right passed it, but the angel once again got him back on the right path.Donald's Better Self. This one is slightly different from other Donald Duck cartoons, because here he is depicted as a child. Perhaps this cartoon was made as a message to the children, telling them to stay in school. There's another Donald cartoon featuring his good-self angel and bad-self devil set during World War II where they convince him to buy war bonds. This cartoon perhaps isn't the best Donald Duck cartoon ever made but it's still pretty good. Any Donald or Disney fan should check it out. From 1938, Donald's Better Self. I recommend it.-

Coz in this he's still a kid going to school. Or at least he should be going to school. He doesn't feel like getting out of bed and his devil side wants to lie in but his angel side convinces him to get up. Then there's the dilemma of either going to school or having fun. Should he go fishing or go to class? Should he smoke a big cigar or do the intelligent thing and refuse it? Obviously the devil and angel start fighting it out with each other instead of bothering with Donald himself. And in the end he does end up going to class. But really, how old is Donald and is he really still in School? Whatever the answer is, it's a funny cartoon.