Frontier Gal (1945)

Too much of everything

One of my all time favorites.

Good movie but grossly overrated

It's fun, it's light, [but] it has a hard time when its tries to get heavy.

Frontier Gal has two exceptionally great features that make the film at least a "7" rather than a "4"- One is the least 20 minutes of the film- fast paced and lots of action (in contrast to the first 60 minutes which was primarily colorful scenes from an old west barroom), breathtaking scenery of the Sierra mountains in California and a great story ending and 2. Miss Beverly Simmons who was fantastic in her role of Mary Ann. From my research on IMDb.com Miss Simmons appeared in only about 4-5 movies, including Buck Privates Come Home. all before the age of fifteen and died too early at the age of 64. I believe her last film was a role in Weekend with Father (1951)for which she did not receive a credit. Miss Simmons was "Shirley Temple" like yet with her own unique charm and terrific acting. I give a 10 to Miss Simmons.

"I'm scorching!" a dizzy saloon girl tells stranger Rod Cameron upon his entrance into the bar to which he responds, "I don't care if you're on fire!", causing a brawl which saloon owner Yvonne deCarlo breaks up with the help of a whiskey bottle. Business goes on however as fists fly with other customers paying little mind to the fight as if it were an every day occurrence. This is a western "Taming of the Shrew" where sexy Rod kisses Yvonne passionately, gets a slap across the face, and simply just kisses her again. He then compares her kissing her to taming a colt, but even then that doesn't mean he wants to keep it, causing the now enamored De Carlo to insist on a wedding. But Cameron is wanted by the law and must serve a six year prison term. Will his feisty bride wait for him or move onto the many waiting admirers or will she drop another bombshell on him? De Carlo speaks with a strange accent which is never identified even though her dubbed singing has absolutely no trace of an accent. Considering that she was a talented singer in her own right (listen to her legendary recording of "I'm Still Here" from "Follies"), dubbing her now seems a mistake, but MGM also did that with future Broadway musical legend Angela Lansbury as well! De Carlo's songs (three of them!) are pretty mediocre ("Set em' up, Joe. We gotta make dough!") although she still looks great, especially in Technicolor. If you want to see De Carlo sing on screen with her own voice, check out the adventure "Flame of the Islands" where she sings a very campy song called "Bahama Mama". She's also pretty handy with a gun, but will it prevent her from being brought down to earth by the very determined Rod Cameron? A scene of her waking up with an empty but worn looking spot in bed gives a definite impression of the marriage being consummated, pretty daring stuff considering the power of the production code.Comic relief by Andy Devine and Fuzzy Knight helps make the unbelievable plot more tolerable. It never rings true that Cameron and De Carlo whose initial meetings are hot but far from loving would just decide to marry out of nowhere. Sheldon Leonard adds the villainy as the man who threatens to come between De Carlo and Cameron, and also the man who killed somebody that Cameron was blamed for. Beverly Simmons is cloying as an annoying little girl who keeps following Cameron all over. The plot moves forward when Cameron's former fiancée (the lady-like Jan Wiley) shows up with aunt Clara Blandick to claim him, making this much more convoluted and complicated than it need to be. So while this is often pleasant, it can be also a bit irritating when the story moves from feisty to family. Fortunately, there is an exciting climax, complete with chase scene, a confrontation between hero and villain near the edge of a cliff, and a riveting scene with the little girl being held captive on a tree trunk that covers a ravine that appears to be on the verge of falling the gorge, and a final great line from Wiley that sums up the difference between the type of relationship which Cameron would have with her than the one he already has with De Carlo.

Poor beautiful Lorena(Yvonne De Carlo) spends most of this rare,for the times, Technicolor B western scowling and throwing things at tall handsome Johnny Hart(Rod Cameron) because he seems to have no heart for her. The romantic relationships in this wacky western make no sense at all! Johnny rides into town, a stranger. Brassy Lorena, who owns and stars in the town saloon, decides he's the right man for her after he brazenly grabs and kisses her in public, not once, but in a series, with a slap from her after each. Soon, she announces to her acquaintances that she's going to marry him. Only trouble is she forgot to ask him if he's agreeable. Horrors, he wouldn't marry her if she were the last woman on earth! Why? Because she's a low class saloon entertainer, albeit a very beautiful and colorful one. Never mind that he's an escaped convict, which she doesn't know about quite yet. Well, Lorena pulls a gun on Johnny and tells him he's gonna marry her, like it or not. He acquiesces. They have a very simple 'shotgun' wedding: no guests, no kiss, just angry looks and words. She spends the rest of the film being furious at Johnny, throwing things at him, even using him for target practice. Yes, hell hath no fury like Lorena scorned!After Johnny returns from a 6 year further prison sentence(which seems more like 6 mins.!), they talk about their future. Johnny asks her if she's going to divorce him. She answers: not if that would make him happy. He discovers he has a 6 year old daughter(Mary Ann). At first, he's not interested in her, but gradually she grows on him after he takes her to his ranch to get her away from the saloon environment. Johnny decides he's going to settle down and raise his daughter, but who is his wife going to be? He decides to invite his old straight-laced girlfriend Shella, who presumably has been waiting for him to reappear all these years! Shella arrives at his ranch with her loud-mouthed spinster aunt. Unfortunately, Johnny's friends thought he meant that he was going to ask Lorena if she would come live with him, which they communicate to Lorena. She sells her saloon and rides out, ready to live with Johnny. Confusion reigns when the various parties meet at his ranch. In the confusion, Blackie, Lorena's long time shady boyfriend, comes and abducts Mary Ann, hoping to lure Johnny into a lethal showdown. He takes the bait and rides after Blackie. Half the town follows a little later. Johnny and Blackie have a long scuffle and guess who wins.Then, Johnny has to rescue Mary Ann, who has crawled onto a precarious log overhanging a large waterfall.After all this trouble, Lorena still has angry words for him when they meet, so he gives her a good paddling over his knee. Mary Ann says that must mean he loves her, and Lorena agrees after a few minutes. Shella has seen enough and pulls out of the romantic competition. End of story. The closing background ballad ends with "If you're gonna be bad, you'd better be good".Well, the plot may be unbelievable, but if you like plenty of colorful man-woman verbal and physical fights, this is the right film. On the whole, it's a fun movie. Johnny also gets into several scuffles with men. The inclusion of Mary Ann as a major part of the second half of the film serves to soften all these negative adult interactions. The inclusion of character actors Andy Devine, Fuzzy Knight, and Frank Lackteen serves a similar purpose. The contest between Lorena and Shella plus her aunt over Johnny very much reminds me of the John Wayne western "Tall in the Saddle", released just the previous year. In that film, a wild cat brunette, rather like Lorena, and a straight-laced blond from the East plus her talkative spinster aunt are both interested in Wayne near the end of the film, and again the wildcat brunette wins.The long spanking scene at the end is what some people most remember about this film. Earlier, Mary Ann had gotten hers. Somewhere, she had gotten the idea that a spanking was a sure sign of love. In the '30s through the '60s, occasionally a Hollywood film would include the male lead spanking the female lead. Some notable examples are seen in 'McClintock", "Across the Wide Missouri" and "Kiss Me Kate" and an "I Love Lucy" TV episode. There were many more, most viewable at You Tube, if interested. In contrast, women spanking men has pretty much been relegated to deviant sexual portrayal films. In some cases, the spanking was an immediate response to a slap or other physical violence by the woman. In other cases, as in the present film, it was a response to a long bout of shrewish behavior. In still other cases, it related to a specific non-violent act by the woman. With the woman's lib movement of the '60s, this sort of thing pretty much disappeared from conventional films and TV.Yvonne spent her early Hollywood years mostly playing temptresses or cowpoke gals in low budget films. Her few A films came later, in "The Ten Commandments" and "Band of Angels", where her dark Sicilian looks were especially appropriate for the plot.As of 2015, this is now available on a no frills DVD and on You Tube.

This is an atypical western. Here there is more humour than suspense, and humour of a timeless nature. When a man loves a woman, or vice versa, there are always trouble spots and the inevitable consequences of the loving union. Take the timeless difficulties between the genders and the mischief of their offspring and you have quite an entertaining and engrossing story. There is a thrilling ending to this romp in the west, and definitely some exaggerated but not politically correct philosophies that reflect the attitudes prevalent in the era when the movie was made. But it is all good fun!